Giving Thanks, Giving Back
by Rabbi Ellen Bernhardt, Community Chaplain and Director of the Jewish Community Relations Committee
Photos provided by Rabbi Ellenhardt
—
As I write this article, we are in the middle of Sukkot, my favorite holiday. Perhaps it is because Sukkot feels like a holiday that invites us to slow down, step outside, appreciate what we often take for granted, and be in community.
We build our temporary dwellings—structures that can be surprisingly fragile and, over the years, have been known to blow over, collapse—and are reminded that we are not entirely in control. This year, the rain has been a particularly persistent guest. Sometimes it is the bees. Yet somehow, despite the weather, the sukkah remains one of the warmest and most inviting places to be.
Inside our sukkah are decorations created by our children and grandchildren years ago, carefully packed away and brought out again each year. There are familiar paper chains, handmade artwork, drawings, and crafts that may have faded a little with time but have become more precious because of it. Each laminated decoration carries a memory. Each one reminds us of a child who was once small enough to make it, and of the generations who have gathered beneath the same roof.
And then there are the guests.
Friends and family are invited to join us, sometimes with little notice and sometimes around a carefully planned meal. When the weather turns cold, there is nothing quite like serving a steaming bowl of soup in the sukkah. We sit bundled together, perhaps a little damp, perhaps laughing about the weather, and somehow the discomfort makes the experience even more fun.
Sukkot is, after all, a holiday about gratitude.
It is the harvest holiday in Israel, at a time when the country was an agricultural one, a time when we acknowledge the abundance in our lives and give thanks for all that we have been given. The sukkah itself reminds us that material comfort is temporary. For one week, we voluntarily leave the security of our homes and live in a structure with open sides and a roof through which we can see the sky.
When the wind blows or the rain comes through the Schach—the branches on top of the Sukkah through which we have to see the sky—we are reminded just how fortunate we are to have a warm, dry home to return to.
Our ancestors wandered in the wilderness on their journey to Eretz Yisrael. Their experience of shelter, food, and security was very different from ours. We have central heating, comfortable beds, fully stocked kitchens, and homes that protect us from the elements. The ancient Israelites lived in these temporary dwellings during their 40 years in the wilderness. Spending time in the sukkah today can make those everyday luxuries feel like blessings again.
Perhaps that is one reason Sukkot has sometimes been described as a Jewish Thanksgiving.
The timing of this issue makes that connection especially meaningful. Thanksgiving asks us to pause and recognize the blessings in our lives. Sukkot asks us to do much the same thing—but then goes a step further.
Jewish tradition teaches us that gratitude should not remain simply a feeling. It should inspire action. Judaism is a religion of action.
If we are fortunate enough to have a warm home, perhaps we can help provide warmth for someone who does not. If our tables are full, perhaps we can make room for someone else’s hunger. If our children have opportunities, perhaps we can help create opportunities for another child. If we have been blessed with time, resources, talents, or connections, we can find ways to share those gifts.
That is where giving back comes in.
There is a beautiful Jewish concept known as tzedakah. Often translated as “charity,” the word actually comes from tzedek, meaning justice or righteousness. Giving is not simply an act of generosity performed by those who have more for those who have less. It is part of our Jewish responsibility to one another and to the community we share.
Sukkot itself reinforces this idea. It is a holiday of abundance, but also one of hospitality. We invite guests into the Sukkah. We celebrate together. We recognize that our blessings are more meaningful when they are shared. It connects us to the 4,000 years of Jewish history.
The lulav and etrog add another dimension to the holiday. We bring together the four species—each with its own characteristics—and hold them as one. The symbolism has been interpreted in many ways, including as a reminder that the Jewish people are strongest when different kinds of people come together as one community.
There is something particularly beautiful about that image when thinking about giving back. A community is not sustained by one person doing everything. It is sustained by many people contributing what they can.
One person may donate money. Another may volunteer. Someone else may deliver a meal, visit someone who is lonely, mentor a child, serve on a synagogue committee, support Israel, help a neighbor, or simply notice when someone needs a hand. Some people give their professional expertise; others give their creativity, their time, their energy, or their friendship.
Every contribution matters.
The sights and smells of Sukkot make this lesson tangible. We see the decorations. We smell the food. We feel the cool autumn air. We hear the prayers in synagogue. We hear conversation and laughter around the table. We experience, even if only temporarily, what it means to step outside the usual comforts of our lives and recognize how much we have.
And perhaps that recognition should change what we do when we step back inside our homes.
There is also an interesting historical connection between Sukkot and the American Thanksgiving season. Thanksgiving, as it developed in the United States, is not simply a continuation of Sukkot, and there is no solid evidence that the Pilgrims were Jewish or that they practiced Sukkot in the “old country.” However, scholars have noted that some early English Puritans were familiar with the Hebrew Bible and looked to biblical stories and traditions for inspiration. The similarities between Sukkot and Thanksgiving—harvest, gratitude, food, community, and giving thanks—make the comparison an intriguing one, even if the two holidays developed independently.
Ultimately, perhaps the most important connection is not historical but human.
Both holidays give us an opportunity to stop.
To look around the table.
To appreciate what we have.
To remember those who helped make our lives possible.
And to ask ourselves what we can do for someone else.
As we move from Sukkot toward Thanksgiving, perhaps we can carry that lesson with us. We may not be able to build a sukkah that never blows over or control whether the rain comes through the roof. We cannot hold on to every blessing forever. But we can choose what we do with the blessings we have today.
We can open our doors.
We can set another place at the table. We can give our time.
We can share our resources.
We can strengthen our community. And we can give back and recognize that this is Jewish way to respond.
Because gratitude is not only about saying, “Thank you.”
Sometimes the most meaningful way to say thank you is to become a blessing to someone else.