By RoseMarie McGill, Educator at Woodbridge High School
—
The Holocaust is—one hopes—firmly ensconced in its rightful place as an indelible stain on humanity. This is not by accident; the human capacity to replace fact with fiction when it serves our purposes is exceptional, and preserving the truth requires superhuman effort. General Eisenhower recognized this instantly. Witnessing the camps, he launched immediate efforts to document the full scope and scale of the atrocities, helping build a protective shield around historical truth. Reinforced over time through survivor testimonies, this shield forces the world to confront an unbearable reality.
Learning about the past is widely accepted as key to preventing it from repeating. Today, over half of US states require public schools to provide Holocaust instruction. As a history teacher, I take that mission seriously, yet teaching this material to today’s high school students is increasingly delicate work.
It has always been difficult to look at such deep and ugly aspects of humanity because it inevitably raises terrifying questions: How could they…? Why did they…? What would I…? Could I…? I often struggle with burdening the minds and consciences of ninth graders with the absolute worst of human history. They are still kids, and they lack personal agency in events from 85 years ago. Disrupted by pandemic-era isolation, their psychological landscape is uncertain. They navigate a daily world rife with incivility and ideological fracturing. The “othering” of people—that evil seed of the Holocaust—is once again budding. If you listen to them, they will tell you the world needs a crash course in growing up.
This, then, becomes the educator’s dilemma: teaching the Holocaust requires balancing historical truth with teaching in an emotionally responsive, student-centered way.
This means not only protecting the mental health of students navigating a tumultuous world, but also adapting instruction in ways that are engaging to today’s learner. If you haven’t been in a classroom in a while, allow me to dispel a common misconception: today’s students are not apathetic or less capable. They are actually deeply intellectually curious; they just want a different kind of learning experience. Technology has given them instant access to facts they can explore on their own; what they want from the classroom is the opportunity to collaborate with peers to explore the human experiences and dilemmas that illuminate the why behind the history.
They reject platitudes like “every tragedy is a neat learning opportunity” and are cognizant that history often repeats itself, despite the fact that people have studied all the relevant facts and timelines. They are hyper-aware of the state of their world and deserve an education that reflects their reality.
So how do we address these issues? We create learning opportunities responsive to their cognitive and emotional frameworks and their deep access to information. Rather than overwhelming them with the crushing weight of every specific historical atrocity, we allow them to grapple with larger philosophical issues that can be applied to the real world. By guiding but not defining, we engender curiosity so that they can seek additional learning on their own.
At Woodbridge High School, we are fortunate to take students to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum annually through a grant from the Halina Wind Preston Holocaust Education Committee, an affiliate of the Jewish Federation of Delaware. Steve Gonzer also visited the school for a Q&A, and the group provided each student with the graphic novel Hidden in Plain Sight. This year, the group gifted my classroom a class set of Simon Wiesenthal’s The Sunflower, which we used as an anchor for evaluating the line between individual agency and systemic guilt.
Before debating Wiesenthal’s core question—whether some crimes are fundamentally unforgivable—students explored the role of human agency. We examined it not only as it relates to the crimes committed by Karl and his peers, but as exercised by Simon in his decision to listen and ultimately forgive or not forgive. We further explored peer pressure, authority, and conformity in our “Verdict Gallery,” where students deliberated on structured scenarios (such as My Lai) to assign blame on a scale from individual to systemic. This activity provided the cognitive scaffolding for students to confront the crimes of the Holocaust and understand them as a deeply human—not just historical—event.
We concluded the novel study with a collaborative “Justice Quilt” project. Each student designed a physical quilt tile that visually represented their philosophical position. They chose a symbolic background color: red for retribution, blue for mercy, or gold for the impossible middle ground. In the center, they spiraled their own “Justice Seed”—the biggest question the book raised for them about justice. Along the border, they wrote their “stitching,” a continuous quote from the book that most challenged their thinking.
When we pieced these individual tiles together into a collective classroom quilt, it visualized exactly what today’s students are capable of achieving. They do not want tidy, sanitized answers to history’s horrors. They want to wrestle with the messy, unresolved gray areas of human nature.
By shifting our pedagogy to honor their intellectual curiosity and safeguard their emotional well-being, we don’t just teach history—we help them build the moral clarity needed to survive it.